This is probably the worst of the various AJs locations. The store is smaller in size than the other locations and has a proportionally smaller selection of products. I used to shop at this location quite frequently as I live in the neighborhood, but I've definitely cut back in recent months as other options have opened up nearby (e.g., Whole Foods).
The main problem with this location is what happens with smaller / low-volume stores: products sit around a lot longer. I've often found mold on some of the less mainstream produce (e.g., pineapples, apricots), I've on several occasions gotten packaged food that was expired, I find their baked desserts to have a dried-out feel / taste to them, and most of their "fresh" bread is hard or stale. I've actually started driving several miles out of my way to visit the 44th street & Camelback location as that location doesn't seem to suffer from those same problems.