My favorite restaurant in Madison, hands down! It's a good place to go with a big group. I take everyone who visits Madison here. I think the cheese curds here are the best in Madison. They also have really good cheese plates. I generally order the chilli, which can be hit or miss depending on who makes it (generally it's pretty chunky, but sometimes it can taste watered down with too much tomato sauce).
On Wednesday nights, they also have karaoke, which just adds to the experience. On weekends, there can be a pretty long wait to get seats.