If you are looking for a classic place with very good (though possibly a half-step short of amazing) food and excellent service in a rustic casual atmosphere, this is it.
The beef tongue and hanger steak were the best choices at our table. The veal sweetbreads were better than average, but you could probably do better elsewhere. The oysters were fresh and had a delicious vinaigrette with them.
The service here is excellent. Our server took great care to explain the menu in detail, refill wine glasses, and make suggestions.
In a great food town, this is a very good choice for the money.