After calling a handful of locksmiths I found Manny and The Car Key Shop. Best price by far, easy to communicate with and just a super nice guy. He remade our truck keys from scratch very quickly. He even went out of his way to put my dog back in my yard after I stupidly left him outside after the job was done and paid for. Hopefully, I never loose my keys again, but if I do, I'll call The Car Key Shop.