Bringing my review back up to 4 stars. Yeah, this place isn't perfect, but its pros certainly outweigh its cons. The best things about the Nitty: I swear by their hamburgers. They are VERY good and very satisfying. My fav is the bleu cheese one... it's fatty and tasty and I'm kind of drooling just thinking about it. The second best thing... birthdays! You get a bday mug (which are awesome collectibles btw) and your choice of free beer or a free grapey mixed drink! It's ideal to invite all your friends and bask in the glory of them watching you drink fo free all night. The third best thing is power hour. Every night, 10-11, $1.50 mixed drinks and $1.00 beers. It's a solid place to pregame for cheap before heading to the bars! Pro tip: they usually don't end it until around 11:15. Once they start playing "The Final Countdown," it's about to end, so scurry on up and order 5 drinks for under $10! Hehe. Basically, the Nitty is a classic and I'll be hitting it up every time I visit Madison... for life.