I am a huge fan of British and Irish ale, which is why you can get me into the door of a place like Trinity, but don't care as much for heavy Irish pub fare. But I was Starving (capital "S" starving) and had to eat something along with that beautiful pour of a Boddingtons on draft. Apparently not that many people in the Whitby area like Irish food either, based on the fact that there were only 4 tables occupied in the joint. This lack of patrons most likely also helps explain the sullen, depressed energy of all the staff. They are all sort of bored & apathetic. With all of this said, my shepard's pie was rich and meaty and hearty - nice & filling on a cold Toronto night. They have nightly specials which you may want to check out, like half-priced starters on Monday. This place has a unique selection of beers and unique menu items that you won't find at most places. That makes it worth investigating!