This spot is good. Really good. I sampled the rib tips and they were a little different from what I'm used to but not in a bad way at all. I ordered them to go and the sauce was served on the side - I actually like that! The sauces are awesome here and the best part is that they are not stingy at all...if you want more sauce - it's available. I enjoyed being able to mix and match and see what combination tasted the best. My favorite is a dip in mustard and a dunk in regular - perfect.
The real surprise here was the Reuben sandwich. This thing delivered in a big way and is absolutely delicious. My dining partner ordered this monster and despite its proportions finished it in no time. I am definitely willing to say that this is the best Reuben in Madison, hands down, and this is no small feat.
I will be back here. Definitely recommend calling ahead for takeout as the establishment is small...they accommodate in house dining - just don't count on it.