My first experience with another Falbo Bros. store years ago was not good. The pizza tasted good, but I was sick the whole next day. Because of this, I've had an aversion to eating there, but since it's my boyfriend's favorite pizza in Madison I decided to give it another try. I'm glad I did!
This time around I went for their Falzone (which is, as you can probably guess, a calzone) filled with chicken and garlic. Some pizza places make you feel ridiculous for having chosen garlic as a topping ("No, I'm super pumped I just paid $2 for a teaspoon of minced garlic I can't even taste with the other toppings! Worth it!), but Falbo Bros. used slices and it was definitely present. The chicken was tasty and found in nearly every bite as well.
I also sampled their cheese sticks, and while it was a bit of overkill with the calzone, it was still tasty and I'd keep them in mind if I was ordering a salad or sandwich.
The Monona location seems to be primarily a delivery and takeout operation - we didn't see anyone dining at dinnertime and the counter is all you can see from the storefront. Our order was ready quickly and traveled home well! I ate the leftovers a couple days later and those also held up after being refrigerated and microwaved.