Pleasantly surprised by this place. Once you take the elevator to the 2nd floor you feel like you're in a different hotel as it has really nice ambiance.
Onion Soup - this was the lone disappointment. The soup literally comes to you in a giant onion but it's all show, no substance as the onion wasn't hollowed out that well so there wasn't much soup. There wasn't much cheese either. I've had better onion soup at chain restaurants which is too bad.
Prime Rib - I would say this was the best prime rib I have ever had. I ordered it medium-rare and it came out perfect with a delicious horseradish cream sauce on the side as well as some au jus. It melted in my mouth and I'll forever compare any future prime rib to this one.
Sides - we ordered the creamed spinach and the red roasted potatoes, both of which were excellent.
Chocolate Banana Cream Pie - quite good, nothing memorable about it but it was a nice way to end the meal.
Service was also spot-on which I appreciated. Do yourself a favor and buy the half-off ticket at a Tix4Tonite location (there's one in Casino Royale). For $6 they will make the reservation for you and you get a coupon for 50% off your main dishes. There are some exclusions (lobster, bone-in filet) but most items quality for the discount and we netted a $23 discount using the coupon. Also, my wife and I dressed up for dinner but we saw some schleps wearing t-shirts and shorts so I guess they take everyone. Given the place wasn't even half-full I can't say I blame them.