I really don't see the fuss. Their ice cream base is lacking in flavor, hence, the ice cream is pretty dull in that department. That being said, their texture is nice and the lemon sorbet is very good (not too sweet and not overly tart). They're also lacking in different flavors (Three kinds of vanilla and three kinds of rainbow sherbet, seriously?) Their prices are terrible considering I'd rather buy a pint of whatever at the grocery store for around the same price as two scoops of theirs. Also their interior is lacking. i understand its an "old fashioned" joint and all but a little decent lighting and a good clean up of the plastic buckets by the door couldn't hurt. All in all I'm giving this 2/5 only because I liked the lemon sorbet and the woman at the counter gave good customer service.