With all due respect to my fellow Las Vegans who rated this place so highly, I must disagree.
Carmine's is, without a doubt, among the worst pizza joints in the valley; let me explain why.
With a name like Carmine's, I'd expect it to serve the kind of pies you usually find across New York City. I mean, this place makes a big to-do about its Italian roots: from the name to the decor to the copies of La Voce (a local Italian-American paper) available inside.
But any similarity to a big-city pizza joint ends once you get your food.
Eating their pizza is like eating cardboard with tomato sauce. You can choke it down, but it's nothing like what you New Yorkers are used to.
Gummy, flavorless and clumsily made, the pizza at Carmines' is even worse than what you can get from the major chains.