I really wish I could do a half-star, as I would give this place 3.5 stars - as I'm torn between 3 or 4.
The location and pure ambience of this place are truly spectacular. It's a timeless, classic that almost makes you think you're stepping back into the 1920's or 30's as part of a grand era of dining reserved only for the elite of that time.
The architecture is pretty incredible too, to which I would recommend eating in the main dining area to soak in the "grandness" of the place. Plain and simple - it's breathtaking...which might be way it gets some higher ratings.
All that aside, the food is just really good...not great or over-the-top in any way. The service is fine, as well...again, nothing to brag about - just solid.
I think this is a place to reserve for special occasions or family get-togethers during holidays, but not something to put on the "regular rotation" for eating. It certainly warrants at least one visit if you're in the area...just don't forget to save up your pennies for this place, as you will not leave without spending some bucks eating here.