Mrs. Pinky and I kind-of-sort-of ended up here by accident. As tourists in Toronto we were off the beaten path, but it was a glorious mistake.
Caesar, the proprietor, was behind the bar. He took care of us. I had a couple of the best cocktails I've ever had --- seriously well crafted mojitos and caipirinhas -- and the food was OK. I wouldn't say it was 5 star food, but we had, without a doubt, a 5 star experience.
I plan to return the next time I am in Toronto and would recommend anyone in the neighborhood to check out Caesar's place.