I was surprised to see that Smitholator Cookie Shop only had a few reviews but not surprised to see that every review is a 5 star. From the feel when you walk into the shop to the cute branding to the sweet smell of baked goods, this shop is on point. She's got a case of delicious, unique cookies and also does uber creative custom orders. I ordered a dozen for my baby shower and people were more than impressed. They looked so good that people didn't want to eat them, my dad actually still has one he kept as a "souvenir". She's got a case of interesting sodas that you can pair with gelato for a soda float. There's a multitude of gluten free options and even cookies kids can take home and decorate with cookie markers.
She also has a shop full of baking supplies and other local vendors' items related to cookies or baking. I love to go in for a quick treat after lunch.