My wife and I decided to try Doolittles for dinner as we'd driven by a few times and the reviews here on Yelp were generally ok.
The atmosphere was pleasing. Wood scent in the air. Clean.. A fine first impression. It was A Thursday note and a Packer game night, so the place was far from full.
We both ordered the half chicken. Mine BBQ. The food arrived surprisingly fast. The fries on my plate were luke warm. The server didn't stop by until I was well into my dinner. I told him of the fries. He apologized and said he'd get fresh. After what seemed like too long, someone else brought fresh, hot fries. (Over seasoned, but hot and fresh)
The chicken was tasty but overcooked. More fat in it than I would like, but that's how chicken is in many places.
We ordered creme brulee for a dessert. Wrong choice. The sugar on top had been over-flamed and had to be scraped off. The custard was underbaked.
Summary? OK food, not-so okay dessert. Average service. It wasn't great, nor was it bad. We'll return and try again.
1/13/18 Update. We returned. I had the half chicken. Much better. Not nearly as fatty. I realize that good lean chicken is hard to find.
My wife had a chicken sandwich. It was quite satisfactory. We had the crime brûlée for dessert. It was properly baked but still overflamed for my preference.
Summary. A place worthy bod another visit with a reminder to self to try the cobbler or cheesecake.