Food - Consistently and awesome. I know what I am getting every single time I order. I have been going here for years and love it. About a year ago they changed their pizza and I don't LOVE the newer style but it is still good.
Beer - You can see it being brewed. Pretty cool thing to have. Their classic 8 are always good and I have never had a bad seasonal.
Service - Great with smaller groups of like 6 or less. Most of the waitstaff are friendly and approachable. Most of them have great suggestions when you ask and give fun, light conversation. I personally have not had the best luck when in a bigger group of say 8 or more.
Atmosphere - It has this crazy way of being a crowded sports bar and restaurant at the same time. I personally love it. Now, I PERSONALLY would not bring kids into this place but people still do it all the time.
NOTES: Secret bathroom - the secret men's room on the east side of the building is funny and weird.
Beer bread - You can get any sandwich (including burgers) on it. I highly recommend this.
Door Men - Super nice guys HOWEVER at a certain point every evening they require ID for entry. THIS IS NOT A BAD THING just don't forget to bring your ID with you.