I have only been once, but I must say it was a treasured experience. It helps that the weather was incredible. The Summer That Never Was had relented when I came to town; it was warm, sunny and perfect. Relaxing and charming, The Rectory fit in nicely. (Having terrific weather and a beautiful outdoor seating area, surrounded by grand trees, certainly helped.) The Lamb Burger was very good if a bit overpriced. The real treat was dessert: an incredible cornmeal olive oil cake -- I'd say shockingly good, but that implies it disturbed my mood. Not a chance. It did, however, tickle my taste buds and warm my soul.
Granted, I was a tourist who didn't even know there was an island in Toronto :-) but the whole experience here was idyllic.