I've had many debates with people about the best pizza in Madison. Given that there's quite a variety of restaurants and styles of pizza, there's a lot of room for debate. However, having sampled nearly every pizza option in Madison, I can confidently say that Pizza Brutta is the best. It's wood fired, Neapolitan style, which is different than a typical NY style pizza or a deep dish Chicago style pizza. And it tastes amazing! I don't know what's in the dough, but the crust is so flavorful. They also provide olive oil for dipping and it's so good, you'll want to drink it. All pizzas are handmade fresh to order right in front of you. It's fun to watch, particularly for kids. Many of their ingredients are locally sourced, which is awesome. And they also make their own mozzarella.
As an example of how amazing the pizza is: We have two young children. It's nearly impossible for all of us to agree on a single restaurant or type of food. Pizza Brutta is the one restaurant that we can always agree on. And the kids always finish their pizza without us having to constantly ask them to finish their meal. It's a miracle!