It pains me to have to update my review from 2 years ago to a lesser rating. We have visited this place frequently since the review and this last visit had to be shared. The food and service we received this last time we were there was sub-par. I had a slice of pizza and an iced tea. Husband had chicken parm that he asked for without the pasta. My slice was good. Hot and crispy. Everything else was bad. Tea was watered down and tasted like water. Tap, not filtered water which is the nastiest water in America. The chicken parm was cold and came with more pasta than chicken. A little piece of over-breadded chicken that was sitting on a cold pile of pasta (that my husband asked to do without). Waitress seemed new and was trying her best, but it was a disaster.
So I guess if you order a pizza to go you will be safe. As for sitting down, I would avoid it until they fix some issues.