Best baked goods in the area, on quality + pricing. People in other bake shops nearby are probably not local. Seems silly to rave about a cookie, but this is a great chocolate chip cookie, crispy at the edges, with the right mix between firm and chewy on the inner portions.
Coffee is good, you won't be amazed but it's hot, fresh, you'll like it well enough.
Pro tip: For amazing value get ginger cake (moist, delicious) or banana bread mini-loaves, at just over $3 they're a steal, I'm used to paying nearly that much for a SLICE.
Outdoor seating when it's nice but this place is strictly take-out in bad weather.