I am not sure why this place has gotten so many rough reviews. I went there with a few friends last month and enjoyed it quite a bit. Like some have said I think I would rather give it 3.5 than 3 stars, as it was enjoyable just not outstanding.
The food was flavorful and nicely prepared, The atmosphere was nice and the owner visited the table while we were there. The service was a tad slow but nothing to get too upset about. Loved the wine selection (a Malbec I think).
Overall this is a place that is close to home for me, cost effective and worth a visit now and then.