I probably picked a very bad night to go, as it was both Friday and Valentine's Day. The wait was very long for both a table and food (so long! like, an hour and a half, but we had nothing better to do), and there isn't a lot of seating so you kind of stand around buying drinks until your waitress tells you your table's ready. Atmosphere is typical loud Friday night bar crowd. Here's why they get four stars- despite the busy-ness, the staff are extremely friendly. The fish fry is the best I've tried in the Madison area thus far. I had the battered cod. I think the tartar sauce is made there, and it is wonderful. The fish tastes fresh, batter isn't soggy like most places, and seasoned perfectly. I think I'll try going back earlier sometime so as not to run into such a huge crowd. I'm glad we stuck it out and waited.