It was our first time here. When we ordered the pizzas and appetizer, I should say that the food wasn't all that I expected.
The pizzas (as pictured) I ordered were the specialty ones; the Hawaiian and Mama Mia. I would like to say that the toppings were somewhat sporadic however it may just because its a 16' ones. The crust was flat in taste but not hard and chewy; just in between. The overall taste isn't special, I guess the tomato sauce isn't zesty enough to bring the pizza to life. Overall, wasn't impressed so 1 star for it.
The appetizer (as pictured) was the bucket of chicken wings. I would like to say it was the most difficult thing to eat. The texture was extremely hard and jerky. The meat was very dry and my mom had trouble "gnawing" at one of the wings. It was so tough having to pull the meat off the bones. lol If I had to compare the texture, it was like the chicken wings were left under the burner for hours at a time and the meat suddenly became tough like rubber bands. Definitely not happy so no star.
There is one particular item that Alexander's Pizza was famous for and that it was its ranch dressing. I ordered 2 pairs in case just so I could try. Lo and behold!!! It was the MOST creamiest, rich, and savory ranch dressing I've ever had in forever! I couldn't compare it to commercially made ranch sauces like Hidden Valley or buttermilk brands. I just imagine it was homemade ones and what lack in the pizzas/wings makes up for in the ranch sauce. So the sauce made eating the pizzas yummy. Impressive ranch so 2 stars for it!
I'd like to say this experience did not throw me off and will continue to explore the other options in its menu. This pizza joint has a prized ranch sauce and I will definitely come back for that with a new item soon. Very friendly and professional staff and that's what kept me attracted to this joint. So 1 star for that.
Would I come back ? A definite yes- for that ranch sauce. Overall 4 star rating.