I can only say that anyone not giving this place high ratings is obviously NOT from NY. This is the real deal.
I drive all the way from north central to get a pie.
For anyone who wants a true 'back home' experience, get the pizza!!
I can't comment on the other items because I can't stop ordering the pizza.
It's true that the girl behind the counter isn't always the friendliest - but hey, that's just like NY too.