Food was ok, but waitstaff was rude and impatient when asking any questions. Hungover? Hate their jobs? Maybe a bit of both? Who knows. Also, if you want a refill on water they'll be sure to roll their eyes and not make it happen. With how great the reviews are, I may try it again but will have low expectations.
Update: Owner reached out to follow up. Places who have owners like this definitely deserve a second chance. I'll update the review to 3 stars, and after my second visit I'll be sure to update it again.