I give them a 5 with a few caveats. After several visits and a few disappointments, I finally found the magic formula. Call them in advance and select todays soup selection. If you go when they have beef barley, you cant go wrong. Its the best of the dozen Ive tried. I would also caution about dining in when its blowing snow as there is no buffer entry door. You can sample everything theyve got, but if you somehow wind up unhappy with your visit, DJ will make it right.