4 stars for the nostalgic interior, 3 stars for the food. This place is a throwback to old school heroes, which makes the place cool as hell and very comfortable. We decided to order french fries as an appetizer and a deep dish pepperoni pizza as our main. There was nothing out-of-this-world about plain french fries (but we know this). When the pizza arrived, I was so disappointed. I guess I am a deep dish pizza snob having previously lived in Chicago, but what really bothered me was the dough wasn't cooked all the way through. It was still raw. I should have known that when I saw the watery substance laying in the pan before I cut into it with a knife. Perhaps Danny Boy's was having an off night, but I don't think it excuses an undercooked pizza. I still think Angelo's and Sainato's both make a way better pizza!