Don't believe all the negativity, it's all sour grapes. This place has solid ratings on every other restaurant review site.
Milagro is relatively authentic, higher end urban mexican faire. Yes, I said authentic. Don't give me this "I lived in San Diego" hipster silliness, the owners lived in Mexico city their whole lives before immigrating to Canada.
Yes, it's a bit pricey, but it's not a run-down dirt hole like most Mexican places are in Toronto. A great addition to the scene.