Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream is so worth it, I once spent $40 to ship two pints to my sister in Michigan!
Every flavor is fantastic, but some of my recommendations are: Fat Elvis (banana ice cream with peanut butter and chocolate), Coconut Almond Bliss (the ice cream version of an Almond Joy bar...it tastes JUST like it!), and my most recent favorite, Triple Zen (green tea ice cream with lemon and raspberry ribbon). And while they no longer make it, I LOVED Oatmeal Cookie! It had huge chunks of oatmeal cookies in it.
A single scoop in a waffle cone is a few bucks, so Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream falls into the "more expensive" category. But if you're going to indulge, I say go for it!