I give this a meh, only because the quality of the pizza seems to be declining. I'd always loved Pizza Di Roma for its New York pizza quality and taste. I don't know if the owner has moved on, or what, but the recipe seems to be changing. I also received a cold and stale pie from EatStreet last week. I'm really going to mourn if the only New York style pizza in Madison -if not the whole state of Wisconsin- has passed.