Get there early, we have showned up twice about half an hour to an hour before closing and there is a very limited selection, which I understand. I love their green Chile cheddar bagel but we have gotten an assorted variety and the sizes and shapes of each individual bagel vary significantly, I am not very experienced with gourmet bagel shops so I do not know if this is a normal practice or if I get the runt of the litter because that's all they have left. I come to this location for convenience since I do business in this area every week but will definitely try one other famous bagel shop close by to compare their consistency and might update my review upon further research.