I, once again, struggled between 3 and 4 stars. As Max stated the wings are fantastic. I've also tried the pizza and the french onion soup. The soup was 4 star and the pizza was 3. Given that Chesterland is really limited on bar / restaurant options, I could see myself making this my weekly hang-out. They really do care about their food quality and making your experience enjoyable.
Good place to watch the game or if you wanted to hide from the wife for a while. If it was just a little closer to SOM then I could see myself bringing friends and family to the Chesterland, but until then, I will make it my usual stop when I decide to take a drive, which turns out to be about 3-4 times a year. Really friendly place so do yourself a favor and stop in.