My wife and I love heading up to My Pie for their $5 Monday classic pizzas. Their pizzas are delicious and an outstanding value, especially at that price. Our favorites are the Mr. White and Grandma's Pie. All of the specialty pizza's we've had are also great. My favorite on that list is the Spicy Butcher.
I think the thing that puts My Pie on top is their ingredients. And they don't skimp, so you have to be careful not to get carried away and put too much on your pizza creation!
My Pie has a dog friendly patio and have offered my dog a pizza pan of water every time she's come with us. :D
Make sure to sign up for the deal program. They really do give you great discounts and free stuff, not just marketing.