The only thing preventing me from giving Pizza BOGO 5 stars is the fact that on every day except Tuesday and Wednesday the pizza is overpriced. Maybe I feel this way because I'm spoiled by the fact that on Tues & Weds I can pick up any Large (8 cut) pizza on the menu or a make-my-own with UNLIMITED toppings for only $6.95 (!!!), sometimes $5.00 with an extra coupon. (The regular menu price is $20 for two larges.)
To me, $20 for 16 slices of pizza is crazy-talk. Especially when Little Caesars is sitting just about across the street offering $5 pepperoni pizzas for pick-up every day of the week.
However, there is no comparison in taste between Little Caesars and Pizza BOGO. Pizza Bogo pizza is consistent, delicious and topping selection is vast - including options like (my favorite) artichoke hearts and pork-free pepperoni and sausage toppings you'd never realize were pork-free unless I told you. Yum. I like the option to upgrade the crust to their "miracle crust" which is made with extra healthy ingredients and whole grains - this crust is slightly more dense than a regular crust but it passed the test when my kids devoured a whole pizza and didn't complain one bit.
So, to sum it up, we're Pizza BOGOers for life, as long as they keep offering the Tues-Wed deal, anyhow.