I wish I could give 3.5 stars, because I am torn. Paul Martin's is just "okay." The atmosphere and servers/service are great. However, the food is nothing to write home about. The selection is rather small, and the price was a little high for what we ate. They also made some odd choices, like the fish tacos are salmon instead of the usual white fish. The portions are a good size, and the French fries and mushroom soup were good. I might try this place again one day, just to see if I can get a truly "4-star" experience.