First of all the only reason I didn't give a one star is because I've never gotten sick at this place.
I've lived in the neighborhood since they opened and have ordered numerous items but the pizza is a regular item for me. There is something wrong with their ingredients apparently because the pizza doesn't taste anything like New York style or anything else for that matter. The pizza dough is completely tasteless and is undercooked to the point of being watery. But it has to be the sub-standard ingredients because pizza from a place that is called "New York Pizza" should not taste like this. The cheese also is totally devoid of any taste whatsoever.
Although, from the outside this place looks so very inviting. The lighting, layout and all, it sets really high expectations... which are quickly dashed the minute you dive into your meal. It's like they really don't know, or care, what they are doing.
While dining in the staff seems like they have better things to do than, well, waiting on tables. Rushing out, dropping off whatever you order and rushing off to hide behind the veil.
But the main reason I will NEVER order from them again is the pizza has NO taste whatsoever. Sorry Mark Rich, New York should not be in your title... and neither should pizza for that matter... adios!