This pet valu is my go to place for cat food.
It's a very small store so they don't carry the large size bags of the food I feed my fur babies, but the staff here have no problem ordering the food in. I can just call them and place the order over the phone so I don't have to go in to the store, and then pay for it when I pick the food up.
In the entire time I've been ordering cat food here (over a year), they only ordered the wrong brand once which I wasn't very happy out, but my cats felt differently and meh, it happens. And it only takes about a week to receive the food you order so that's good too!
Sometimes when I'm here I can't find the prices for stuff (like cat litter), so it sometimes makes me not want to buy things because I don't like having to ask. The cat litter here might also be a little more expensive than the grocery store, (hard to know for sure without prices on everything). Also, I think the stuff here is mostly for dogs and then cats, and the selection is pretty limited in general but more so for other animals; that's my only criticism but the store is what it is and it's great. Buy your cat food here =D