One of my (and many other people's) favorite places in Madison! I'm a huge fan of a good old fashioned and true to their name & claim - they make a great one. Great beer selection as well and I have seen them run night specials on specific craft beers a few times already, which is a nice way to try something new. I've only dined here 2 or 3 times and every time I get a burger but I've never been disappointed and I think the beef is local which is always nice. Of course, the cheese curds are highly recommended but we all already know that ;P.
Oh, I have yet to not have seen them be super busy, even on a weeknight evening & they do not take reservations. Something to keep in mind if you would like to sit down and eat dinner here!