Very good meatballs earned them their 3rd star. The pizza and salad were only worth 2 stars. Pizza was disappointing. Very watery. I'd suggest that they pre-cook their mushrooms to prevent this. Not enough cheese on pizza. Pizza sauce too watery, not enough flavor to sauce. Good crust.
Greek salad disappointing. Not enough of the good stuff; very light on feta, kalamatas, no pepperoncinis.
If this is authentic NY style, then Ill stick with Chicago style.