3 1/2 stars. I'll round this review up to 4 this time. Why? Because they have upgraded their "everyday $3 beer" from Magic Hat #9 to a Black IPA that is just delicious. The IPA is made specially for Bites and Brews and Buffalo Blues by Penn Brewery. Try it!
While they still have their simple menu of choosing your own pizza and toppings, salad, or sandwich, they have unfortunately increased their offerings to include overpriced, underwhelming appetizers. Fried pickle slices or cheesy breadsticks in the shape of a pizza have some potential as good bar snacks, but they're just unappetizing.
That being said, their original menu is still awesome, and they've expanded their space so finding a place to sit during happy hour isn't as tough. When the weather is warm, they have tables set up right on Ellsworth. The beer selection is usually very good, and it's $1 off drafts from 5 - 7pm.