After reading their reviews I knew we had a 50/50 shot on our visit. It is an interesting entrance complete with the sliding window like an old speakeasy. The Host with his thick accent (Chicago not NY) welcomed and seated us right away. The place is on the darker side as far as lighting but adds to the mood. The menu's come with small LED flashlights to read them.
As usual we get the "forgetful" server but had I would imagine a floor Manager check on us and she got our drinks right away and no issues after that. The bread is ok, not their home made but was warm and the garlic butter was good. We tried the Caesar salad with pasta and meatballs. Its a different combination and now we can say we tried it and something different next time.
My wife's eggplant was very good and that is her signature dish to try when we go out. My Spaghetti and Meatballs was good (not the best I have ever had and not the worst). We skipped dessert so you are on your own with that if you go.
We enjoyed ourselves and would go back again for another shot and recommend it as well.