I was a little disappointed here. It seemed like it would be a really good dining experience, but there were a few aspects of the meal that put me off.
Garfield's is hidden in a residential lake-side shopping center. You'd never find it by chance unless you lived in the area. I believe they have valet service (I saw the valet podium, but no valet attendants), but there is plenty of parking in the lot.
If you can eat outside, the view is beautiful -- especially around dusk. Unfortunately we were continuously pestered by little gnats. I spent quite a bit of my time trying to swat the things away. I've eaten at Marche Bacchus (just 50 yeards away) and they didn't seem to have the same problem. I'm not sure whether they do something to keep them away -- it may have been just the luck of the draw that night.
I felt the experience was a bit over priced. Before my friend got there, I had two vodka tonics and was very surprised to see the bar bill was $24. The meal for two came out to around $75 -- not exorbitant, but I thought the food was just mediocre. Of course, I just got fish - which is hard for me to get too excited about.
The ambience there is nice and it's a good for a romantic and relaxing meal. Just be prepared for a larger than normal bill for a meal that is just so-so.