I've lived in Madison my entire life, so the fact that I had not been to this establishment before last night is shocking to me. From the moment we made reservations, to when we were walking out after dinner, the staff was so incredibly friendly and attentive.
We started out at the bar - which, is still the original bar from 1929 (with some refurbishing), where Al Capone and John Dillinger and some other gangsters used to hang out.
We had "The Godfather" martini (vodka, pineapple juice) and the "Tommy Gun" (bourbon, cherry juice) - I recommend both.
We were seated upstairs for dinner. Our waitress told us a well-rehearsed history on the Wonder Bar, and added that it is now considered a certified haunted establishment! (This is a thumbs up in my book!) Our steaks were made perfectly, the salads and sides were just as good. Try the cheesy hash browns. Oh! And as an appetizer, get the crab cakes.
The prices are decent for the amount and quality of food you receive. I will be back!