I just realized I forgot to write a review after I dined here months ago... so I'm a little fuzzy on the details, e.g. what menu items we ordered, vintage/vintner we drank (I do recall it being a smooth Pinot Noir), etc. Oh well. The impression of the evening was lasting nevertheless.
I recall the menu being a la carte, and the prices somewhat steep. Those two factors can make for a very hefty bill at the end of the night -- and it did. The food is great, but not world-class great... Harvest is a big fish in a small pond. When compared on an international or even just a national stage, it would be awarded a consolation prize, but certainly no medals.
The service was impeccable and the atmosphere was immaculate... and I'm keeping this review relative to the small pond of Madison, so these factors bump its rating to a solid 4 stars. I'll recommend it, and I may even be back -- just as soon as I check out L'Etoile.