This is the first time we've stopped in at Fatty Daddy's but based on the reviews and pictures, we were intrigued. The dessert with cookie and toasted marshmallow was the only "special" dessert item. They were out of most flavors and the one they had that we thought looked good was not. Chocolate Nutella was disappointing to the point that my wife and I threw it away. It's saying something if my wife throws away ice cream. We stopped at a gas station for a pint of Ben and Jerry's. It was much better. Again, though, our only time there and it was late. The staff was friendly.