This is more like 3.5 stars. The rock fish was excellent -- buttery. The marlin, perhaps as typical for this fish, dense, but nicely moist. The Thai crab curry soup amazing -- perfect blend of coconut milk with some spice kick and lemongrass. I love the intimacy of the place, but it was a bit loud (and yucky coffee to end). The service was attentive and warm, but not overbearing. All in all worth the $$ and a nice treat for a special night.