Food Quality & Price: Dishes were pricey but food was good. My husband and I especially loved the beef carpaccio appetizer. Both of our mains were satisfactory. The fusilli with beef tenderloin was saucy and cooked well, the beef tenderloin entree was reasonably proportioned. I was disappointed that both my first choices were not available at the time (kitchen did not have veal or osso bucco). We each had Prosecco at $10 per glass (perfect choice that night).
Facility: We were seated on the patio which was large and spacious. Seating was comfortable and by night fall, they switch on some romantic mood lighting. Originally they were going to seat us indoors (in a little corner), but we opted for the patio. It was chilly but definitely worth the switch. It was quieter, more romantic and airy.
Service: Our servers were attentive and accommodating. Absolutely no complaints about it. They kindly took photos for us and cleared away dishes efficiently.
Overall: We had a lovely experience at Il Postino and were very glad to have tried it here. It's a great place to dine at least once. I am unsure if we would return however as the experience didn't leave a remarkable impression. I wouldn't object to returning but wouldn't seek it out for exceptional quality food or service. Perhaps lunch would be better?
As I am unable to leave half stars, I rated Il Postino a 3.5/5, rounded up for how much my husband liked it.