Unpretentious and Old School, we went there on a Thursday night when there just happens to be live jazz! The Academy Burger was delicious, and rumor has it this place hasn't changed in ages.
Our waitress had a hairstyle that I've never seen in person before - only in 1960s movies. The overall aura of the place is ancient and dive-y... they have after-dinner drinks like Brandy Alexanders and beers served in frosty mugs.
I really enjoyed my food but let me warn you: if you come here seeking gourmet, you've missed the point. Pictures of their dark and vintage-y interior, plus the interior of the delicious Academy burger - are on my blog. (http://whatsincleveland.blogspot.com/2011/07/academy-tavern-larchmere.html)