I have to sat when they 1st opened a couple of years ago, I wasn't totally impressed by Carmines but after trying different items and time has passed, they've surpassed themselves.
We generally grab a pie before a sins game. I love white pizza-they've got it. Calzone, wings, pasta, etc... I tried my 1st sandwich there (roast beef with cheese hot) and the bread was so fresh and the meat/cheese was delicious- I made my hubby take a bite! I'm glad I was in the mood to try a new item there.
With plenty of shared seating outside with Maria's and a good amount inside, Carmine's is a great place to grab a quick slice pre-game or a whole pie (yes, they'll make a whole pie for you during the busy times).