I didn't know anything about this place, but someone in my running group suggested we stop in here after a run for a birthday. I thought it was delicious!
I think I've said this in other reviews involving dessert type stuff, but I'm pretty easy to please when it comes to sweets. Also, I'm more of an ice cream & cookie person (opposed to cakes or pies) so The Baked Bear is right up my alley.
There's a good amount of cookies & ice creams to choose from (actually, I would say there's quite a bit of cookie options). They also do brownies & donuts (and you can combine if that tickles your fancy).
I wanted to guarantee I had a safe combo that went together so I went w/a salted caramel sugar cookie (which was the cookie of the month) & salted caramel ice cream. I had it warmed up. Surprisingly, the cookie warmed up perfectly & the ice cream only slightly softened and didn't melt. They cookies aren't huge, but decent enough size and I thought tasted really good (it's hard to say how fresh they were since they were warmed up). I also thought the ice cream was tasty and they use a good amount of it.
I thought the prices were good for what you got. I believe my sandwich was $4.95. The brownie & donut sandwiches are a little bit more. Everyone I was with liked what they had and the birthday girl got her treat for free :)